The Wagner Advantage
Cost, Choice, and Customer Service.
We know choosing insurance is about more than just finding the lowest price. It’s about trust, local commitment, and having options when you need them most. We simplify the entire process by focusing on the three pillars that set an independent agency apart:
We stand behind our promise of better service and value. Don’t just take our word for it—see what our clients in Olmsted Falls and Northeast Ohio are saying.
Your Insurance Questions, Answered
We believe in making insurance simple and transparent. Here are the most common questions we hear from our neighbors in Olmsted Falls and Northeast Ohio.
Because we care! We are members in our community and have a responsibility to make sure you are properly insured at a reasonable price! We want to be able to look you in the eye when we run into you at the supermarket and know that you are taken care of. We pay local taxes and support our local schools and community with fundraising activities. Why would you want to work with someone who is not invested in your community?
Unlike other agents, an independent insurance agent is not tied to one insurance company. You don’t need to change agencies as your insurance and service needs change. An independent agent offers one-stop shopping and can compare plans from many companies, giving you the broadest range of coverage at a competitive price. One call puts you in touch with someone who can do the comparison shopping for you.
Erie Insurance (founded 1925), Grange Insurance (founded 1935), and Ohio Mutual Insurance (founded 1891) are very reputable and financially sound. Each is rated A+ or better by A.M. Best. You can compare insurance companies at the Ohio Department of Insurance website or check ratings directly at A.M. Best.
We are proud members of the Northeast Ohio community. Our office is located at 9696 Columbia Rd. in Olmsted Falls, Ohio, and we serve the entire state.
Get started today. We promise to respond to your quote request in less than 24 hours.
