Your Local, Independent Insurance Partner.

Serving Olmsted Falls, Greater Cleveland and the State of Ohio since 2008

The Wagner Advantage
Cost, Choice, and Customer Service.

We know choosing insurance is about more than just finding the lowest price. It’s about trust, local commitment, and having options when you need them most. We simplify the entire process by focusing on the three pillars that set an independent agency apart:

Local Customer Service

We are members of the Northeast Ohio Community—just like you. You get personal, responsive assistance with everything from policy questions to claim filing. Our goal is to make sure you are properly insured and always taken care of.

More Choice, Better Coverage

Unlike captive agents, we are not tied to one insurance company. We partner with many reputable and financially sound carriers like Erie Insurance and Grange Insurance to ensure you have the best coverage options available.

Competitive Cost

Because we shop from multiple insurance companies, we can find you the coverage you need at the most competitive price possible. We constantly look for savings, sometimes even noticing a price increase before you do!

Find Your Perfect Policy

Auto Insurance

Home Insurance

Life Insurance

Commercial Insurance

Real Stories. Real Savings.
See Why Your Neighbors Trust Wagner.

We stand behind our promise of better service and value. Don’t just take our word for it—see what our clients in Olmsted Falls and Northeast Ohio are saying.

      EXCELLENT  
   Based on 184 reviews 
    
 
 
 
   
 
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   kristen wagner 
 27 days ago
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. was able to get insurance fast and the coverages i needed! thank you!
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   Donna Allen 
 102 days ago
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Establishing my new insurance policies through Wagner Insurance was easier than any I’ve set up in the past with other companies.  Gina was very efficient, friendly, and easy to talk to. She got me great rates for both home and auto with a reputable company I’d hoped to be insured with. Gina was very patient with all my questions and answered them quickly and thoroughly, making sure I completely understood my coverage and options and pricing with each option. I’m so pleased I chose Wagner for my coverage.
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   Denise Roberts 
 105 days ago
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Great experience very helpful and informative, I spoke to several Insurance and they were by far the most helpful and affordable.  thank you
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   Asaad Jawhari 
 152 days ago
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I had a very good experience with Wagner insurance. Joe helped me and put everything together faster than I expected. Very professional and dedicated to his business
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   mikias green 
 180 days ago
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Very transparent and honest, great work with.
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   Kathy Caldwell 
 186 days ago
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Joseph Wagner was so thorough & helpful finding me a better price on home & auto insurance. I highly recommend this agency!!!
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   Jacob Loos 
 200 days ago
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Awesome customer service, very responsive, great options/pricing. I had been with my previous insurance company for close to 10 years, one call to Wagner saved me thousands of dollars a year!
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   Marty Matus 
 405 days ago
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Joe Wagner was very personable and knowledgeable. He helped us get the coverage we needed and made the entire process quite easy.
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   Ayesha Ameer 
 416 days ago
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Mr. Wagner is one amazing insurance agents I have ever came across. He treats you with respect and as a family member . I am happy to do business anytime with him and will definitely be referring other people to him
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   Larry Helyes 
 512 days ago
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Joe has been very helpful in securing new policies.  It's difficult to charge carriers but with rates swinging so quickly he made the process more manageable.  Thanks

Your Insurance Questions, Answered

We believe in making insurance simple and transparent. Here are the most common questions we hear from our neighbors in Olmsted Falls and Northeast Ohio.

Why use Wagner Insurance Group?admin2025-12-15T14:44:02+00:00

Why use Wagner Insurance Group?

Because we care! We are members in our community and have a responsibility to make sure you are properly insured at a reasonable price! We want to be able to look you in the eye when we run into you at the supermarket and know that you are taken care of. We pay local taxes and support our local schools and community with fundraising activities. Why would you want to work with someone who is not invested in your community?

Why use an independent insurance agency?admin2025-12-15T14:44:02+00:00

Why use an independent insurance agency?

Unlike other agents, an independent insurance agent is not tied to one insurance company. You don’t need to change agencies as your insurance and service needs change. An independent agent offers one-stop shopping and can compare plans from many companies, giving you the broadest range of coverage at a competitive price. One call puts you in touch with someone who can do the comparison shopping for you.

How can I find out more about the companies you represent?admin2025-12-15T14:44:02+00:00

How can I find out more about the companies you represent?

Erie Insurance (founded 1925), Grange Insurance (founded 1935), and Ohio Mutual Insurance (founded 1891) are very reputable and financially sound. Each is rated A+ or better by A.M. Best. You can compare insurance companies at the Ohio Department of Insurance website or check ratings directly at A.M. Best.

Where is Wagner Insurance Group located?admin2025-12-15T14:44:02+00:00

Where is Wagner Insurance Group located?

We are proud members of the Northeast Ohio community. Our office is located at 9696 Columbia Rd. in Olmsted Falls, Ohio, and we serve the entire state.

Ready to Experience the Wagner Difference?

Get started today. We promise to respond to your quote request in less than 24 hours.