Wagner Insurance Group

An Independent Insurance Agency
Personal InsuranceBusiness Insurance

Providing affordable personal and business insurance since 2008

Serving Olmsted Falls, Greater Cleveland and the State of Ohio

Wagner Insurance Group Logo Cropped Whitespace

Why use Wagner Insurance Group?


Because we’re local – we have been since 2008.

And we care about YOUR needs – always have, always will.

About Us

Auto Insurance

Whether you drive an SUV, minivan or just cruise your classic car on weekends and holidays, we can find an auto insurance policy to fit your needs.

Home Insurance

Your home is one of your most important investments.

Protect yourself and your  family against accidents in your home or on your property.

Life Insurance

You have insurance for your home and car. That’s all the insurance you need. Right?

What if something happens to you? Is your family provided for?

Business & Commercial Insurance

You’ve worked hard to make your business successful.

Protect your livelihood from unexpected losses in your day-to-day operations.

Recreational Vehicle Insurance

Whether you’re new to RVing, a “weekender” or it’s your lifestyle, we make sure you have the right insurance policy for your next trip.

Boat and Personal Watercraft Insurance

Whether you’re out on the water every day or your watercraft is in storage, keep your boat, Jet Ski or other “toys” protected year-round.

Motorcycle Insurance

Customize a motorcycle policy for peace of mind on and off the road, whether you’re enjoying a long summertime ride or you have your bike stored for the season.

What is an Independent Insurance Agency?


An independent insurance agency offers products from multiple insurance companies, saving you the hassle of looking for coverage for you, your family and your business.


Our insurance industry experience, customer service and knowledge of YOUR needs makes us second-to-none. See some real-life examples of how we have helped our customers in the next section.

Independent agents offer lower cost policies

Paul and Michelle were shocked at the cost to add their teen daughter to their current auto insurance policy. One call to Wagner Insurance Group and they saved $1000 by moving to a company that has better rates for teen drivers.

Al and Lidia had been with the same insurance company for years – and for no reason, their auto insurance went up by $500! Wagner Insurance Group noticed the increase before Al and Lidia did, called them and provided a new policy that saved them close to $2000 per year AND increased their insurance coverage!

Click on the button below to get your free auto insurance quote today!

Independent agents offer more insurance choices

Jon owns a detective agency and needed an insurance policy tailored to his business needs and risks.

Most of the “big name” insurance companies won’t even quote an insurance policy for this type of business.

But Wagner Insurance Group has relationships with several specialty business insurance companies and found Jon a policy at a very reasonable price.

Click on the button below to get your free business or commercial insurance quote today!

Independent agents offer better customer service

Darlene had several recent home insurance claims – none of which were her fault.

Her insurance company paid for a new roof and a water back up claim but advised her they would no longer insure her home due to her multiple claims.

Wagner Insurance Group advised her of the insurance policy problem and was able to move her to a new company with similar coverage with little effort required from Darlene.

Click on the button below to get your free homeowners insurance quote today!

Ready For Your Free Quote?

Just call us, text us or fill out our Request Form using the buttons below to have us
provide you with a custom quote.